Background
UNTUCKit is a New York-based men's apparel brand founded in 2011, best known for pioneering shirts designed to be worn untucked. What started as a direct-to-consumer brand has grown into a leading retailer with over 70 stores and a strong online presence.
Challenges
As a leading retail brand with a large customer base and a wealth of data, UNTUCKit recognized the significant potential of A/B testing to optimize the shopping experience and drive growth.
But turning that potential into results was a challenge. Their previous testing platform required significant development resources for every test, and like many other leading Shopify brands, UNTUCKit had limited development capacity and competing priorities.
As a result, launching tests and reaching statistical significance took far too long, leaving valuable growth opportunities untapped.
The team needed a faster, more efficient way to test ideas and drive measurable results without relying on developers.
So they switched to Visually. Here's what made it stand out:
- High-velocity testing, made possible by the ability to build and launch tests independently with AI, without relying on developers.
- In-depth test performance analytics, including evolving odds of winning and results broken down by traffic source.
- A constant stream of test ideas and proven best practices to keep experimentation moving.
- Outstanding support that feels like an extension of their team.
In just 4 months, we had more tests and wins than in a full year with our old vendor. The AI, constant inspiration, actionable analytics, and phenomenal support make Visually really stand out.”
Napon Pintong
Senior Manager Ecommerce
Outcome
In just a few months with Visually, UNTUCKit has already achieved impressive results, delivering 199X ROI. Here are a few of their wins:
Product Page: Social Proof
The team ran an A/B/C test on product pages, displaying the social proof message “XX added to cart in the past day” either above the Add to Cart button or above the product name.
Both versions outperformed the control, proving the power of social proof. But placing the message above the product name was the clear winner, driving an impressive 28.2% conversion rate uplift, likely because shoppers saw it immediately, without scrolling, giving them more confidence to move toward the CTA.
Here's where it gets even more interesting. Breaking down the results by traffic source revealed that most of the uplift came from Google Ads visitors. So the team rolled out the winning version to 100% of Google Ads traffic and started testing different versions for other sources.
Result: +28.2% conversion rate
Cart Drawer: Upsells
The team tested adding Visually's personalized upsells to the cart drawer, showing each shopper relevant products based on their individual shopping behavior.
The upsell component also featured an image zoom option, allowing shoppers to examine products more closely without having to leave the cart to visit their product pages.
Additionally, product reviews were displayed alongside the upsell products, adding social proof and helping shoppers make more confident purchase decisions at this critical stage of their journey.
Result: +4.5% average order value
Product Page: Sticky Add-to-Cart
To keep adding to cart top of mind and make it easier for shoppers to take action, the team tested a sticky Add to Cart button that appears as shoppers scroll past the main CTA.
Interestingly, in addition to driving more add-to-cart actions through the new sticky button, the test also increased clicks on the main CTA. This suggests that the sticky button served as a reminder, encouraging some shoppers to scroll back up and add products to their cart using the main button.
Result: +2.5% add-to-cart rate
Visually gives us a much deeper understanding of how shoppers engage with our store. We can see how different traffic sources respond to our tests and optimize accordingly, while the detailed performance metrics help us uncover interesting insights and opportunities.”
Napon Pintong
Senior Manager Ecommerce
Personalized Experiences
Beyond A/B testing, UNTUCKit uses Visually to personalize on-site promotions based on traffic source and campaign UTMs.
Different marketing campaigns often feature exclusive offers for specific audiences. With Visually, UNTUCKit can now display these offers on the website, matching the promotions shoppers encountered through Google Ads, Meta, email, or SMS, while keeping them visible only to the relevant audience.
This creates a seamless, consistent experience from the initial marketing touchpoint to the website, reinforcing promotional messages and encouraging shoppers to convert.